Occasionally a secular type Muslim confesses to me that my hijab intimidated them when we first met. Like, they thought I would be kind of narrow and holy-moly before they got to know me. They assumed I would judge them and give them fiery lectures when they erred. A lot of more outwardly religious type Muslims are like that, I guess. There really are some of us who blurt things out in an attempt to intimidate others towards faith. I think of myself as a sort of Middle Path person, so I try to avoid that sort of thing unless it is a very well placed mini-lecture. But I guess I should take the painful experience of dealing with the more zealous Holy-Molies into consideration when analyzing one of the typical and easily categorized reactions to hijab, so as to be less taken aback by it.
An example: At my daughter’s class birthday parties there are these women of Muslim backgrounds but who are sort of upper class or elites in their home countries and they are very posh looking, surgery-fied and show up for toddler parties wearing the latest fashionable outfits and tall high heels. Their housemaids chase the kids while they chat amongst each other. For them, hijab is “lower class.” These women hardly talk to me, probably because they think I am judging them. Well, I am judging them, I suppose. But not in that “You are going to hell, you harlots of tabarruj” sense. More like, “Wow, I couldn’t even tell she had a nose job because the last birthday party was in dim lighting but now that we are in direct sunlight I can see the nose job and lip injections. How could I have missed that before?” kind of way. But they think I am judging them in the Holy-Moly way. I leave the first kind of judgement up to God. And I tell myself to stop being so shallow and silly with regards to that other catty innervoice (geeze, I guess I am pretty shallow about some things). But I can tell that I make these women uncomfortable. Their husbands jump 5 feet out of my path because of the hijab. They behave very awkwardly around me. They look down and avoid my eyes. One time a woman of this sort said to me out of nowhere, “You are so good wearing hijab and you are not even an Arab. I would like to wear hijab, but I am not ready. But you are so much better than us! God bless you.” That revealed a lot to me. First of all, I am not better than any one of them, and only God knows what is in their hearts. Also, hijab has nothing to do with being an Arab. That aside, these women are comfortable as they are in their closed settings with their friends and family members, but in the broader picture in their countries they are looked down upon for not towing the party line and wearing hijab. They probably get lots of comments from people who would like to see them covered up (which I feel is an individual choice, and no one should be bullied into it!). So when they see me, it could somehow remind them of that sort of thing. They are bearing a social burden by not being covered. They are seen by their societies as the opposite of the goodness embodied on the image of a woman who dresses like me. That must be another reason I make them uncomfortable.
Another example: One of my husband’s cousins confided that he was afraid of me when we first met. (I am the only one in the entire khaandaan who wears a headscarf except for one other bahu who lives in America) Because of my scarf, he had expected me to be something different. He had his own (mis)perceptions about scarf wearing women in the Pakistani context. He was relieved that I turned out to be “nice and easy going.” It hadn’t even occurred to me that anyone would ever feel afraid to meet me, but now that I look back on other interactions between my rather secular extended in-laws, I can see their perceptions of hijab coloring our initial conversations.
All I can say is that I really think religiousness is personal. I really could care less if these people choose to cover or not. It is their business. I have enough to worry about looking after my own errant soul. I feel increasingly non-spiritual these days. My mind concentrates more on worldly things and occasionally strays toward the depths of vapididity (noticing nose jobs and so forth). I believe in hijab for myself, and I need to practice some heart softening activities. But to some people, my outward appearance is conveying a Holy-Molyness that I just don’t possess. It aslo strikes me how much class and ideas of religiosity are so intertwined for some people. Anyhow, it is hard to imagine how li’l ole me could possibly intimidate anyone, but I guess I do scare some people! Boo!
February 26, 2009 at 4:49 pm
I think so often hijab is not adopted for religious reasons at all. I know people who don’t pray or fast and do all sorts of things that shock me, but they make sure that not a single hair is showing…
But then again, I sometimes feel pretty intimidated by the hijabis, esp. on white converts. Mostly only at the mosque, there are a couple of groups of these hijabi converts who all seem pretty close and have never so much as given me and my hairline a second glance. I feel like they’ve already judged me as not pious enough to befriend. Unfortunately, I don’t think your “believe in it for me but I’m not going to judge YOU” thing isn’t universal. Of course, I’ve been know to have these kinds of things made up entirely in my head.
*cough* all the desis are staring at me *cough*
February 26, 2009 at 5:00 pm
Excellent post. I admire this type of attitude, and I wish more Muslims would display it. I wear my headscarf in a more “African style,” meaning that I basically just cover my hair and ears, but not my neck and earlobes (I wear earrings). Sometimes, I feel intimidated when I see women wearing “Arab-style hijab” because I have gotten comments before saying that the way I wear it is “not right.” I won’t comment on whether or not anyone is correct or incorrect in their assessment of my scarf and how I choose to wear it. But I will say that, like you, I wear my scarf for me and not for anyone else, and I wear it in a way that is comfortable for me. I think everyone is at their own stage Islamically, and it is nobody’s responsibility to judge simply because of what one wears (or does not wear). My applause to you, sis!
February 26, 2009 at 7:40 pm
Don’t judge the book by its cover
I guess we all make assumptions about people we meet from first impressions or on how that person is dressed(hijabi or not).
February 26, 2009 at 8:15 pm
People need to get over themselves! I can’t imagine living life while being so insecure that someone else’s head scarf would make me “feel judged.” That’s such vanity!! “Wow! The world cares soooo much about ME that everyone is paying attention to ME and making judgements about ME!”
We live in such a me-centered society. The next time someone tries to make it out that it’s *your* fault that *they* feel judged, tell them to quit being so vain and you have far more important things to worry about then them!!!
February 26, 2009 at 10:38 pm
On Halloween night I once walked through the mall here in North Little Rock, Arkansas and I noticed a couple of women staring me down before I quite reached them. Just as I approached them I said, “Boo!” and they looked very surprised. Then I said, “Happy Halloween!” and the burst out laughing. As I went on my way I heard one say to the other, “Now that was funny…”
Sorry, your story just reminded me of that, and I felt that sharing it was ‘called for’.
We all have our little inner jihads. The way we dress doesn’t make us different than anyone, as women or as human beings. People should not judge a book by its cover, but unfortunately we all do it at times.
February 27, 2009 at 6:41 am
Assalamu Alaikum,
Duuuude (that was the ‘dude of total agreement’, by the way. I said it to a sheikh the other day. I am offically way too Amurrican)… yeah, hijab is such a personal choice for me, that I forget that other people feel that I’m making a judgment on them because I’m wearing it.
I learned the hard way, a long time ago, that 99% of the time, no one is thinking about me at all- or better said, that whatever people say, it’s always about themselves- so it always takes me aback to hear someone voice the ‘oh, you’re better than me’ schtick.
Good to see you around again.
February 27, 2009 at 8:53 am
Your bit about how hijab is seen a lower class is so true. When I meet new people in gatherings or walk into a shop in Pakistan, I am usually ignored as if I don’t know how to speak. Finally when I open my mouth to reveal a British accent, everyone stands to attention and their attitudes make a 180 degree turn. It’s happened to me for so long now that I just find the reactions amusing.
February 28, 2009 at 1:22 pm
Manal and I have tended to find that we get along with people who are not so outwardly religious, especially those who make that claim themselves.
I dont know what it is, but so many people who claim to be religious, and try to act religious, tend to be the least decent of the lot.
We have met women in hijab who confess to being religious, yet their actions are anything but. Same with the men in beards.
Hijab or not, it doesnt make a difference. We dont judge people based on such shallow identifiers because we have learned it means nothing. You can have a lady in hijab or a man in a nice Sunnah beard treat you in the most unreligious of ways and be treated in the best way by a person whose religiousity isnt meant for show, something for public consumption.
Looks can be deceiving, and that holds perfectly true for hijabs and beards as it does for anyone else.
It is best not to let these things get in the way when you meet people because more often than not they dont really tell you anything about a person.
March 1, 2009 at 5:33 pm
I don’t agree
You have choosen to present yourself to the world in a robe and scarf which have a meaning, otherways I don’t think you would bother to wear something so ugly and cumbersome! and I’m not insulting anyone but it’s supossed to be the reason, no? present yourself ugly before the world so your husband is the only one to see your beauty.
Having said that, I must add that I respect the decission of the individuals who take this way but if you take a decission you must be prepared as well to assume the consequences and receive different treatment.
March 2, 2009 at 10:26 am
querida extranjera: I am modest, not UGLY! And my clothes are hardly cumbersome.
“but if you take a decission you must be prepared as well to assume the consequences and receive different treatment.”
Maybe all “different” looking people like me and others should just stay at home rather than expect society to be just and tolerant!
March 2, 2009 at 8:43 pm
dear fatima
. I met some time ago a very nice man from the M’zab (Algeria) where women wear a white thick veil from head to toes and they only show one eye. Well, my friend would swear that there were sexy ways to wear this veil! and there are modest ways to wear a bikini. It’s just your attitude.
I haven’t said you are ugly but that the main purpose of the abaya and the hijab is to make look women ugly!! (it’s a very different thing). And about modesty, that lies in your heart and your head
And about the different treatment it must not be by force bad or despective at all! just you are showing you’ve got certain beliefs and are not interested in certain things.
It’s not a question of tolerance. Each one has the right to believe and practice whatever feels but if you dress in a certain way you are saying you don’t want to be part of certain things
anyway.. no bad feelings. do as you like
greetings
March 3, 2009 at 1:21 am
Salaam Alaikum,
Foreigner – So when I’m walking along the street with my baby in her pram and some man says how he hates “converters” and wants to shoot us all, that’s totally acceptable just because I’ve chosen to wear a white scarf on my head?
March 5, 2009 at 6:16 pm
thats a really nice post…being a hijabi myself who intimidates others on the first meeting, i can so well relate to it
March 9, 2009 at 3:59 pm
When a door is slammed in your face, God opens seven more for you…
March 9, 2009 at 4:28 pm
Safiya Outlines, not at all. that’s a completely rude and horrible thing to do! I was saying a very very different thing. The different treatment is about socializing with other people who doesn’t know you very well and that what Fatima was talking about in the first place. That’s something logical, normal and human. You present an image to the world and the world reacts to it at first sight. I have no prejudices at all and many Muslim friends but it was a bit slower or different the process of getting intimate with them because you don’t know how they could think about certain things and if you could make certain jokes… not right, not wrong..just different.
and with that I think I’ve explained all that I wanted to say with my comment which has been so badly misinterpretated!!!
March 9, 2009 at 6:28 pm
foreigner, I live in a country where many women are covered and it is not an unusual sight. by your theory, everyone should treat uncovered women here in a negative way since they don’t fit the norm and seeing them elicits some kind of visceral reaction that cannot be controlled by inclusiveness and politeness, since they are different. that is just plain wrong, just as wrong as people judgeing and mistreating me (the two go hand in hand) for being covered.
By the way, if you are not sure if a joke is okay to tell around someone, that is probably your inner-conscience informing you that the joke is racist. Who would want to insult people they consider to be friends with racist jokes?
March 11, 2009 at 4:58 pm
dear Fatima,
You don’t want to understand what I want to say because you are in each answer twisting things and saying thinks I never said!
So, don’t worry that this is the last time I’ll write a comment as communication is imposible.
June 4, 2009 at 3:10 pm
Salaams, I gave you some “link love” on this article.
I added it to my head-covering blog carnival.
May 13, 2010 at 1:24 am
I just came upon your blog (really random: I was searching for Gujarati Haleem recipes because I like how they use balsamic vinegar as a condiment for haleem…) You are so articulate mashaAllah and a keen observer of, well, everything! I’m supposed to be grading final exams for my “Women in Islam” class, and instead have found myself surfing your blog for the last (oh my God!) 45 min. 1) I could not believe you were desi and 2) was amazed with how adept you are with so many different languages (this is a classic line: “You are going to hell, you harlots of tabarruj”!!!) so I spent all this time trying to find some reference to the fact that you’re actually an INDIAN (ya’ni Hindu)-American convert to Islam. Then I find this post about you going to a non-desi non-Muslim (and I’m assuming, white) wedding. So I guess you really aren’t desi somewhere back there. I wish you and I could meet! It’d be fun to have random conversation with you!
salam, distant sisterly-admirer
May 15, 2010 at 6:08 am
Salaam sister, I am white American indeed. My husband is Pakistani! You are most welcome back anytime
You sound like an interesting person yourself. (Women and Islam Class? Gujarati style haleem…seems we are interested in the same things!!!) Wassalaam!